Discussion Board
There are no previous messagesGo to the following message
Current Forum: Homework 5 General Forum
Date: Fri Nov 16 2001 4:28 pm
Author: Liu, Limin Angela <laliu@andrew.cmu.edu>
Subject: grading: correctness and robustness

Since there are almost unlimited number of corner cases out there, what will the grading policy be in terms of correctness and robustness of the program?

Here are a few cases I can think of at the moment: Assume all links are good, and there is no obvious grammatical mistakes in the html source file, say missing tags, or the like:

1. if the official solution returns 10 links for a particular query, will the correctness be based on whether or not the 10 links are all returned? And also with the same ranking?

2. if the delta function and action table are modified, but still can't handle all possible cases, or even causing exceptions in uncommon ones, will these exceptions cause grade loss?

Or, as long as after WebCrawler is called (there might be some exceptions thrown for uncommon cases), WebSearch can return a reasonable amount of links with the right ordering according to their indegrees, full credit for correctness will be given?


Post response

There are no previous messagesGo to the following message
Current Thread Detail:
grading: correctness and robustness      Liu, Limin Angela      Fri Nov 16 2001 4:28 pm       
Re: grading: correctness and robust...      Cipriani, Jason A.      Fri Nov 16 2001 11:07 pm       
Re: grading: correctness and rob...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 9:30 am       
Re: grading: correctness and rob...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 9:32 am       
Re: grading: correctness and rob...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 12:37 pm       
Re: grading: correctness and ...      Ghosh, Debmallo S.      Sat Nov 17 2001 4:01 pm       
Re: grading: correctness a...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 6:03 pm       
Re: grading: correctness a...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 6:12 pm       
Re: grading: correctnes...      Ghosh, Debmallo S.      Sat Nov 17 2001 6:37 pm       
Re: grading: correct...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sat Nov 17 2001 7:42 pm       
Re: grading: correct...      Liu, Limin Angela      Sun Nov 18 2001 2:59 pm       
Re: grading: correctness and robust...      Goodman, Brian J.      Sat Nov 17 2001 1:09 am       

Back to previous screen