Discussion Board
Go to the previous messageGo to the following message
Current Forum: Homework 1 Forum
Date: Mon Sep 10 2001 4:14 pm
Author: Knop, William James W <wknop@andrew.cmu.edu>
Subject: Re: Handin and grading

The way I see it, the only difference is that a couple variables and a one liner function would get moved into the abstract class and out of the extention classes. If the assignment stated that we should design it specifically to be very expandable and scaleable, then code simplicity (and readibility, in my opinion) would have to be sacrificed.

I don't understand why it is so important that it be so easily extendable from the start (would that it be extended in the future). Really, one can copy paste the code, change a few lines and the conversion is all done in around 3 minutes. Had I known that expandibility had such high importance, I'd have implemented accordingly.

In any event, how many points of the 20 do you think will be allocated to this abstract class?

-Will
Post response

Go to the previous messageGo to the following message
Current Thread Detail:
Handin and grading      Venugopal, Ashish R.      Sat Sep 8 2001 4:40 pm       
hw1.jar      Venugopal, Ashish R.      Sat Sep 8 2001 5:06 pm       
Re: Handin and grading      Zhang, Jingfeng      Sat Sep 8 2001 5:15 pm       
Re: Handin and grading      Kohl, Charles M.      Sun Sep 9 2001 12:17 am       
Re: Handin and grading      Knop, William James W      Sun Sep 9 2001 12:10 pm       
Re: Handin and grading      Tanz, Ophir      Sun Sep 9 2001 7:12 pm       
Re: Handin and grading      Lee, Peter      Sun Sep 9 2001 9:26 pm       
Re: Handin and grading      Knop, William James W      Mon Sep 10 2001 4:14 pm       
Re: Handin and gr...      Lee, Peter      Mon Sep 10 2001 11:35 pm       
question about node.java      Nidhiry, John J.      Sun Sep 9 2001 1:22 pm       
Re: question about node.java      Goodman, Brian J.      Sun Sep 9 2001 1:30 pm       

Back to previous screen